Case Study - Working Relationships
Following a home accident, Paul was granted one week's sick leave. The following week, Paul did not report for work and had telephoned to say he had been unable to come in for the rest of the second week. Paul's manager accepted the situation and agreed to allow Paul an additional week sick leave. However, this continued for the next four weeks at which point Human Resources contacted Paul to try to ascertain the severity of the situation.
Human Resources felt that the injury was not severe enough to warrant four week's leave and asked for a new doctor's certificate to substantiate Paul's claims. After failing to provide this, the organisation felt that it had to take disciplinary action. This appeared to distress Paul a great deal and he was very concerned for his job.
Paul then agreed to partake in an informal assessment with a WSM Occupational Psychologist to see if there were any other issues involved in Paul's long term absence.
On further investigation, it was revealed that Paul and his manager had regular disputes regarding how to approach new work and projects and this often lead to very stressful work environments for both of them. This had continued for so long that it was considered, by Paul's colleagues, to be normal working practice between Paul and his manager. However, it was unknown that Paul had started to suffer from stress-related illness including anxiety and mild depression. Paul suggested he even saw the injury as a positive release from his work.
Discussions continued with Paul and his manager and a report then produced to outline the main issues. It appears that Paul and his manager clearly had very different personalities and working methods and as such their discussions and meetings had become a forum for arguments rather than finding solutions to the work problems.
Strategies to improve relations between Paul and his manager were suggested and Paul returned to work within two weeks of the assessment date. Paul feels that the interventions have helped him to feel valued and respected in his role, while also being respectful of the obvious personality differences between him and his manager. |